Jake Moffatt needed to fly home for a funeral. When he contacted Air Canada about bereavement discounts, the airline's AI chatbot confidently told him he could apply for a refund after his trip. The bot explained the policy in detail, even providing specific instructions on how to claim the discount.
There was just one problem: the policy didn't exist. When Moffatt tried to get his refund, Air Canada told him they don't offer post-travel bereavement discounts. But the damage was done. A Canadian court ruled that Air Canada had to honor their AI's promise, costing the airline real money and setting a legal precedent that companies can be bound by their chatbots' hallucinations.
This isn't a glitch in the matrix. It's what AI researchers call a hallucination. And for customer experience leaders, it's becoming one of the most critical challenges of our AI-powered age.
What is an AI hallucination?
Think of AI hallucinations like a confident employee who makes up answers when they don't know something. Instead of saying I don't know, they create what sounds like a perfectly reasonable response. Only, it's completely wrong.
In technical terms, an AI hallucination occurs when artificial intelligence generates information that appears plausible but has no basis in its training data or reality. The AI isn't lying. It genuinely believes what it's saying is correct. It's more like a vivid dream that feels real while you're experiencing it.
Dr. Emily Bender, a computational linguistics professor at the University of Washington, puts it simply.“A language model is a system for modeling the distribution of words in text... Its fundamental task is to take that model of distribution of words in text and use it to come up with a plausible next word, and then the next word and next word, and so on."
When asked if ChatGPT is basically autocomplete, she responds: "Yes. Another phrase, that I can't claim credit for…spicy autocomplete.”
For customer experience teams, this creates a unique challenge. Your AI might sound confident and helpful while delivering completely incorrect information about your products, policies, or procedures.
Why do AI hallucinations happen?
Understanding why AI hallucinates requires an understanding of how these systems work. Most customer service AI tools use large language models, like ChatGPT or similar technology. These models learn by analyzing billions of text examples, identifying patterns in how words relate to each other.
Imagine teaching someone a language by showing them millions of conversations, but never explaining what the words actually mean. They might become incredibly good at mimicking natural speech patterns, but they'd have no real understanding of the concepts behind the words.
That's essentially how most AI works. It learns that certain words tend to follow other words in specific contexts, but it doesn't truly comprehend what those words represent in the real world.
Three main factors contribute to AI hallucinations:
Pattern completion over truth: AI systems are designed to complete patterns, not verify facts. When asked about your return policy, the AI might generate a response that sounds like a return policy, even if it contradicts your actual terms.
Confidence without knowledge: AI doesn't express uncertainty the way humans do. It won't say "I'm not sure" or "Let me check on that." Instead, it presents every response with equal confidence, whether it's accurate or completely fabricated.
Training data gaps: If the AI hasn't been trained on specific information about your business, it might fill in the gaps with plausible-sounding but incorrect details.
Common AI hallucinations in customer experience
CX leaders report several recurring types of hallucinations that can damage customer relationships and brand trust:
Policy invention: AI creates shipping policies, return windows, or warranty terms that don't exist. Like a company discovering their chatbot was promising customers a "48-hour network issue resolution guarantee" for a policy that never existed.
Product feature fabrication: AI describes product capabilities, specifications, or availability that aren't real. Like an electronics retailer's AI assistant told customers about a "waterproof mode" on devices that had no such feature.
Promotional confusion: AI generates discount codes, special offers, or pricing that isn't valid. Customers receive codes that don't work or promises of sales that aren't happening.
Procedure misrepresentation: AI explains processes for returns, exchanges, or technical support that don't match actual company procedures, creating confusion and frustration.
Inventory hallucinations: AI confidently states product availability without checking real-time inventory, leading to overselling or disappointed customers.
How to spot AI hallucinations
Detecting hallucinations requires systematic monitoring and clear warning signs. Here's what to watch for:
- Inconsistent information: If your AI gives different answers to the same question across multiple interactions, hallucinations are likely occurring.
- Overly specific details: When AI provides very specific information it shouldn't have access to, like exact delivery times for orders it can't track, be suspicious.
- Policy deviations: Regular audits comparing AI responses to actual company policies often reveal hallucinations.
- Customer confusion: If customers frequently contact human agents saying "your chatbot told me..." followed by something that sounds wrong, investigate immediately.
- Impossible claims: AI might promise things that violate physics, company capabilities, or basic logic.
Building hallucination-resistant systems
The goal isn't to eliminate AI from customer experience. The benefits are too significant. Instead, smart CX leaders are building systems that minimize hallucination risks while maximizing AI value.
Ground AI in reality: The most effective approach involves connecting AI to real data sources. Instead of asking AI to remember your return policy, integrate it with your actual policy database so it can look up correct information.
Define clear boundaries: Train AI to recognize the limits of its knowledge. Effective systems teach AI to say "Let me connect you with a specialist" rather than guess.
Implement human oversight: Critical interactions should include human review before reaching customers. AI can draft responses, but humans verify accuracy.
Regular testing and auditing: Systematic testing of AI responses against known correct answers helps identify hallucination patterns before they reach customers.
Customer context matters: AI performs better when it has rich context about each customer and their specific situation, rather than operating in a vacuum.
The trust equation
Here's what many CX leaders miss: the goal isn't perfect AI. It's trustworthy AI.
Customers can forgive honest mistakes or limitations. They can't forgive confident misinformation. An AI that says "I don't have access to real-time inventory, but I can connect you with someone who does" builds more trust than an AI that confidently provides wrong inventory numbers.
The companies succeeding with AI in customer experience aren't those with the most sophisticated technology. They're the ones that have learned to balance AI capabilities with appropriate guardrails and human oversight.
The evolution of AI
The AI hallucination challenge is driving rapid innovation in customer experience technology. New approaches are emerging that combine the efficiency of AI with the reliability customers expect.
Advanced systems now fact-check AI responses against databases before presenting them to customers. Some use multiple AI models that cross-verify each other's answers. Others employ "uncertainty detection" that identifies when AI might be hallucinating and routes those interactions to human agents.
The most promising development may be AI systems designed specifically for customer experience, rather than general-purpose models adapted for CX use. These specialized systems understand the unique requirements of customer service: accuracy over creativity, reliability over innovation, and customer satisfaction over impressive-sounding responses.
Practical steps for CX leaders
If you're implementing or managing AI in customer experience, consider these immediate actions:
Start with low-risk interactions while building confidence in your AI systems. Simple FAQ responses and basic account information are safer testing grounds than complex policy questions or sensitive customer issues.
Invest in comprehensive training data that reflects your actual business operations, policies, and procedures. Generic AI training isn't sufficient for customer-facing applications.
Create clear escalation paths for AI uncertainty. Train your systems to recognize when they're approaching the boundaries of their knowledge and smoothly transition customers to human support.
Monitor and measure hallucination rates as actively as you track customer satisfaction scores. What you measure, you can manage.
Turning hallucination risk into trust
AI hallucinations aren't a reason to avoid artificial intelligence in customer experience. They're a reason to approach it thoughtfully.
Companies that master this balance by leveraging AI's efficiency while maintaining accuracy and trust will create significant competitive advantages. Those that ignore hallucination risks may find that their AI cure becomes worse than the disease they were trying to solve.
Your customers don't need perfect AI. They need reliable, honest, and helpful experiences. Understanding and managing AI hallucinations is how you deliver exactly that.
The future of customer experience isn't about choosing between human and artificial intelligence. It's about combining them in ways that amplify human capability while maintaining the trust and accuracy customers deserve.
And that future starts with understanding exactly what your AI doesn't know, and teaching it to admit it.
Recommended Blogs
Machine learning in customer service
Find out how machine learning is changing the landscape of customer service and how you can keep up.
Neural networks, explained: a guide for CX leaders
Unlock a new era of CX with neural networks. This deep dive reveals how brain-inspired AI delivers personalized customer experiences and boosts efficiency.
AI evals for AI — sounds sci-fi, leads to improvement
Alice Li breaks down AI evaluation frameworks: manual vs automated, key tradeoffs, and the importance of human oversight. Essential reading for product teams.